The right rewards credit card is one of the few financial products that actually pays you to use it — as long as you're disciplined about paying your balance in full every month.
Canadians are well-served by some of the world's best credit card reward programs. But without a strategy, most people leave hundreds of dollars on the table each year. Here's how to change that.
The Three Types of Credit Card Rewards
1. Cashback
The simplest reward type. You earn a percentage of every dollar you spend back as cash — typically deposited to your account annually or monthly, or available as a statement credit.
Pros: Easy to understand, guaranteed value, no blackout dates
Cons: Generally lower ceiling than travel points
Good for: People who want straightforward value without managing a rewards program
Top Canadian cashback cards currently offer 1.5–2% back on all purchases, with 3–4% on specific categories like groceries or gas.
2. Travel Points (Airline Miles)
The classic rewards play. You earn points per dollar spent, then redeem for flights, upgrades, and hotels. The key programs in Canada:
- Aeroplan (Air Canada): The dominant Canadian travel program, partnered with Star Alliance. Points can be redeemed with dozens of airlines globally
- Avios (British Airways Executive Club): Often excellent value for short-haul and business class redemptions
- WestJet Rewards: Straightforward dollars-off-flights model
Pros: Potential for outsized value (business class redemptions can be worth 5–10x cashback value)
Cons: Requires research and planning; availability can be limited; programs can devalue
Good for: Frequent travellers willing to optimize their redemptions
3. Flexible Points (Bank Rewards Currencies)
Bank-issued points that can be transferred to multiple airline or hotel programs, or redeemed directly against travel bookings:
- American Express Membership Rewards: Transfers to Aeroplan, Avios, and many others
- TD Rewards: Used through Expedia for TD or transferred to Aeroplan
- Scotiabank Scene+: Redeemable at Empire grocery stores, Cineplex, and for travel
- RBC Avion: Transfers to British Airways, Cathay Pacific, and others
Pros: Flexibility; can optimize based on redemption availability
Cons: Slightly more complexity; bank portals often offer lower value than direct airline redemptions
How to Choose the Right Rewards Card
Step 1: Know Your Spending Patterns
The highest-earning card for you depends on where you actually spend money. Run your numbers:
- How much do you spend on groceries per month?
- Gas?
- Restaurants?
- Online shopping?
- Travel?
A card offering 3x on groceries is worth more than one offering 2x on everything if groceries are your biggest category.
Step 2: Decide If You'll Travel
If you have no interest in flying business class to Europe, a cashback card will serve you better than chasing Aeroplan points. Be honest about your lifestyle.
Step 3: Consider the Annual Fee
Most premium rewards cards charge $99–$699/year. These fees are often worth it if:
- The welcome bonus exceeds the first-year fee
- The card's ongoing rewards value + perks (travel insurance, lounge access, etc.) outweigh the annual fee
- You can meet the minimum spend to earn the welcome bonus
Step 4: Check the Welcome Bonus
Welcome bonuses can be worth $200–$1,500+ in points or cashback. They're a major part of the value equation in year one — and a legitimate reason to switch cards periodically.
5 Strategies to Maximize Your Rewards
1. Use One Card for Everything (Until You Level Up)
Simplicity first. Pick the best all-around card for your situation and put all your spending on it. More points in one place = faster accumulation.
2. Stack Bonuses on Accelerated Categories
Many cards offer 2x, 3x, or even 5x points on specific categories. Use your grocery-optimized card at the grocery store, your travel card for travel bookings, and your all-around card for everything else.
3. Hit Welcome Bonuses Strategically
Some Canadians open a new card before a large planned expense (home reno, vacation, a wedding) to hit the minimum spend quickly and earn a large welcome bonus. This is legitimate — just don't overspend to hit a target.
4. Optimize Your Redemptions
This is where the real leverage is. Redeeming Aeroplan points for economy flights might yield 1.2 cents per point. Redeeming for business class on a partner airline might yield 4–5 cents per point. The same points, 3–4x the value.
5. Never Carry a Balance
Credit card interest rates (19.99–24.99%) will obliterate any rewards value in weeks. Rewards credit cards are only profitable when paid in full, every month, without exception.
The Mistake Most Canadians Make
Collecting points across five different programs and never having enough to redeem for anything meaningful. Pick one or two programs, focus your spending, and accumulate to a redemption threshold before diversifying.
BudgetSmart Tip
Track your monthly spending by category in BudgetSmart to identify where you spend the most. That data tells you exactly which reward categories to prioritize — and whether a premium card's annual fee is worth it based on your actual spending, not a hypothetical average.
Used strategically, a good rewards credit card is one of the simplest ways to extract extra value from spending you'd do anyway.
Frequently asked questions
What type of credit card rewards are best in Canada?
It depends on your goals. Cashback cards are simplest and best for people who want guaranteed value. Travel points (like Aeroplan or Avios) offer outsized value when redeemed for business-class flights but require more planning. Flexible points cards (like Amex Membership Rewards or TD Rewards) offer a middle ground.
Is it worth having multiple reward credit cards in Canada?
Yes, for disciplined spenders. A common strategy is a strong everyday card plus a specialized card for categories like groceries or gas. Just avoid carrying balances — interest charges will wipe out any rewards value instantly.
How much are Aeroplan points worth in Canada?
Aeroplan points are worth approximately 1.5–2 cents each when redeemed for flights, though premium cabin redemptions can yield 3–5 cents per point. Redeemed for merchandise or gift cards, the value drops significantly.
Do credit card rewards count as taxable income in Canada?
Generally no. The CRA considers most credit card rewards to be a discount on purchases rather than income, and they are not taxable. There is an exception if you earn rewards through a business and deduct the expense — in that case, the rewards may be considered a taxable benefit.
How can I avoid losing credit card rewards points?
Make at least one purchase per year on your account to keep it active, ensure your contact information is current, and read the fine print on expiry rules. Aeroplan points, for example, expire after 18 months of account inactivity.
Stop guessing where your money goes
Budget Smart AI tracks your spending, finds silent money leaks, and forecasts your cash flow automatically.
Start Free Trial