STOP LOSING MONEY ON AUTOPILOT — Find forgotten subscriptions & money leaks in minutes · 14-day free trial · Full access to every AI feature · Cancel anytime◆STOP LOSING MONEY ON AUTOPILOT — Find forgotten subscriptions & money leaks in minutes · 14-day free trial · Full access to every AI feature · Cancel anytime◆STOP LOSING MONEY ON AUTOPILOT — Find forgotten subscriptions & money leaks in minutes · 14-day free trial · Full access to every AI feature · Cancel anytime◆STOP LOSING MONEY ON AUTOPILOT — Find forgotten subscriptions & money leaks in minutes · 14-day free trial · Full access to every AI feature · Cancel anytime◆STOP LOSING MONEY ON AUTOPILOT — Find forgotten subscriptions & money leaks in minutes · 14-day free trial · Full access to every AI feature · Cancel anytime◆STOP LOSING MONEY ON AUTOPILOT — Find forgotten subscriptions & money leaks in minutes · 14-day free trial · Full access to every AI feature · Cancel anytime◆
Debt PayoffMay 26, 2026·5 min read

Consumer Proposal vs. Bankruptcy in Canada: Which Is Right for You?

When debt becomes unmanageable, two formal legal options exist: a consumer proposal and personal bankruptcy. Here's an honest comparison so you can make the right call for your situation.

By BudgetSmart Team

Consumer Proposal vs. Bankruptcy in Canada: Which Is Right for You?

When debt stops being manageable and starts feeling impossible, two formal legal options in Canada can provide real relief: a consumer proposal and personal bankruptcy. Both are administered by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), both stop collection calls and interest accumulation, and both eventually clear unsecured debts. But they work very differently — and choosing the wrong one costs you.

Here's the full comparison.

What Is a Consumer Proposal?

A consumer proposal is a legally binding offer to your creditors: you'll pay back a percentage of what you owe, over up to five years, in affordable monthly instalments. Creditors holding the majority of your debt must agree to it. In practice, creditors accept most proposals because they recover more than they would in a bankruptcy.

Key facts:

  • Available if your total unsecured debt is under $250,000 (excluding a mortgage)
  • You keep all your assets
  • Interest stops the day you file
  • Collection calls stop immediately
  • No surplus income payments required
  • Takes 3–5 years to complete
  • Credit impact: noted on your report for 3 years after completion

What Is Personal Bankruptcy?

Bankruptcy is a legal process that eliminates most of your unsecured debts in exchange for surrendering non-exempt assets and making income-based surplus payments for a set period.

Key facts:

  • No maximum debt limit
  • Non-exempt assets may be surrendered (vehicle above provincial exemption limit, non-registered investments, home equity above exemption)
  • Interest stops the day you file
  • Collection calls stop immediately
  • First bankruptcy: 9 months (or 21 months if surplus income applies)
  • Credit impact: 6–7 years after discharge

Side-by-Side Comparison

Factor Consumer Proposal Bankruptcy
Maximum debt $250,000 (unsecured) No limit
Assets Kept Non-exempt may be surrendered
Duration Up to 5 years 9–21 months (first time)
Monthly cost Negotiated lump-sum / 60 payments Surplus income payments
Credit report 3 years post-completion 6–7 years post-discharge
Upfront cost $0 $0
Public record No Yes (public database)

When a Consumer Proposal Makes More Sense

Choose a consumer proposal if:

  • Your debts are under $250,000
  • You have assets you want to keep (home equity, car, RRSPs)
  • You have a steady income and can afford monthly payments
  • You want a shorter credit recovery window (3 years vs. 6–7)
  • You want to avoid the public bankruptcy record

Example: You owe $60,000 across four credit cards and a line of credit. You're earning $65,000 per year. A consumer proposal might settle all $60,000 for $25,000 paid over 5 years — that's $417/month, far less than minimum payments on $60,000 of high-interest debt.

When Bankruptcy Makes More Sense

Consider bankruptcy if:

  • Your debts exceed $250,000 (consumer proposal limit)
  • You have no significant assets to protect
  • Your income is low enough that surplus payments won't apply
  • You need the fastest possible discharge (9 months vs. 5 years)
  • You cannot afford even a modest proposal payment

Example: You owe $400,000 and have minimal assets and income. A consumer proposal isn't available at that debt level. Bankruptcy discharges the debt in 9 months.

What Happens to Your Assets?

This is where the two options diverge most sharply.

In a consumer proposal: You keep everything. Your RRSP, TFSA, car, home equity — all protected, provided you keep making proposal payments and continue to pay secured creditors (mortgage, car loan).

In bankruptcy: Provincial exemptions protect some assets. In Ontario, for example, you can keep a vehicle worth up to $7,117, household goods up to $14,180, and RRSPs (except contributions made in the 12 months before filing). Anything above those thresholds may be sold by the trustee and distributed to creditors. Home equity above the exemption is typically surrendered.

What Debts Are NOT Covered?

Neither option covers:

  • Student loans less than 7 years old
  • Child or spousal support
  • Court-ordered fines or restitution
  • Debts from fraud or misrepresentation
  • Most student loans under 7 years

The Credit Score Impact

Both damage your credit — the question is how much and for how long.

A consumer proposal is rated R7 while active and stays on your credit report for 3 years after your last payment. If your proposal takes 4 years plus 3 years post-completion, that's 7 years total — similar to bankruptcy. But if you pay it off early, the clock on removal starts sooner.

Bankruptcy is rated R9 (the worst rating) and stays on Equifax for 6 years after discharge in most provinces (7 years on TransUnion). A second bankruptcy stays for 14 years.

In both cases, you can start rebuilding with a secured credit card immediately after filing.

How to Get Started

The first step is the same regardless of which option you choose: consult a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. The initial consultation is always free. An LIT is a federally regulated professional — not a debt settlement company — and they are legally required to explain all your options, not just the ones that earn them the most.

Search for an LIT through the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy at ic.gc.ca, or visit firms like MNP, BDO, Grant Thornton, or Farber. Many offer same-week appointments.

The Bottom Line

If you have assets to protect, income to make payments, and debt under $250,000, a consumer proposal is almost always the better choice. It costs less in the long run, protects your assets, and clears from your credit report faster.

If your debt is overwhelming, your income minimal, and you have nothing to lose, bankruptcy provides the fastest legal discharge.

Either way: the consultation is free, the advice is regulated, and the relief is real. Don't wait until it gets worse.

Frequently asked questions

What is a consumer proposal in Canada?

A consumer proposal is a legally binding agreement, filed through a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), in which you offer to repay creditors a portion of what you owe over up to five years. It stops collection calls, halts interest, and protects your assets.

What debts can be included in a consumer proposal or bankruptcy?

Both cover most unsecured debts: credit cards, personal loans, payday loans, lines of credit, tax debts, and NSF fees. Exceptions include student loans less than 7 years old, child support, alimony, and fines/penalties.

How much does a consumer proposal cost?

There's no upfront cost. The trustee's fees are built into the payments creditors receive — they're paid from your proposal payments at regulated rates set by the federal government. You never pay the trustee separately.

How long does bankruptcy stay on your credit report in Canada?

A first-time bankruptcy stays on your credit report for 6–7 years after discharge (Equifax keeps it 6 years in most provinces, TransUnion 7 years). A second bankruptcy stays for 14 years. A consumer proposal stays for 3 years after completion.

Can I keep my house or car in a consumer proposal?

Usually yes. In a consumer proposal, you keep your assets as long as you continue payments on any secured debts (mortgage, car loan). In bankruptcy, non-exempt assets may be surrendered depending on your province's exemptions.

How do I find a Licensed Insolvency Trustee in Canada?

Search the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy's public registry at ic.gc.ca or visit one of the major insolvency firms (MNP, BDO, Farber). The initial consultation is always free.

consumer proposalbankruptcy Canadadebt reliefinsolvencyLicensed Insolvency Trusteedebt payoff

Stop guessing where your money goes

Budget Smart AI tracks your spending, finds silent money leaks, and forecasts your cash flow automatically.

Start Free Trial

Keep reading

How to Pay Off High-Interest Debt in Canada Fast

High-interest debt is the biggest obstacle to building wealth. Here's a practical, step-by…

The Best Debt Payoff Strategies for Canadians in 2026

Carrying debt in Canada? Discover the most effective debt payoff strategies for 2026 — fro…

Debt Consolidation in Canada: Options, Pros, Cons and How to Choose

Juggling multiple debts with different interest rates is exhausting and expensive. Here's …